Log in

No account? Create an account
Irishfest bummer - Phil's Rambling Rants — LiveJournal
August 19th, 2007
08:40 pm


Previous Entry Share Next Entry
Irishfest bummer
As I have for the past several years, I headed up to Milwaukee this weekend for Irishfest.  I couldn't take time off work this year, so I had to leave Friday after work and come home today, which means I could only go Saturday.  This is usually OK; I've done it before.  But this year, it rained pretty much the whole day.  During the day, things went on mostly as normal, though the crowds were thin, but in the evening, they closed down most of the stages.  In particular, Leahy was rained out.  Our group spent most of the day at the Celtic Roots stage which had a tent.  Unfortunately, with the exception of Liz Carroll and John Doyle, who were of course awesome, I found the acts much less wonderful than the others in our group.  Liadan was not bad; they're technically good and sounded pleasant, but they didn't really grab me, and a couple of the other acts really struck me as trying to be Celine Dion rather than trying to be Irish.  The day had gotten started on the wrong foot when we were almost there and I realized I had failed to transfer my earplugs to something I brought with me.  We spent at least 20 minutes looking for a place where I could buy some while I sat there being mad at myself and feeling like my stupidity was hurting everyone else in the car, and it ended on a bad note when I walked all the way from the Celtic Roots stage at the north end of the park to the Pabst stage at the south end to find that it was dark, because while they'd told us that the Leinie's Rock Stage was closed, they hadn't mentioned that any of the others were.  So I walked all the way down the park in the cold, soggy rain, alone because nobody else wanted to hear Leahy anyway, and then turned around and walked back and listened to music I didn't like that the others seemed much happier with.  We wandered south to the Tipperary stage where a band called Scythian that seemed to me to be trying to be a fusion of Celtic with bad current club music.  They were loud (fortunately I had the earplugs), they were enthusiastic, their audience was drunk and happy, but while there were some pieces of what they were doing that were good, the whole package was awful.  As soon as the people in our party who'd bought things to eat or drink had finished them, we wandered on, past Gaelic Storm who were dreadfully loud but not that interesting to the Snug, where a group called Millish was playing the most interesting music of the evening to a crowd of perhaps 20 people.  They melded jazz and rock influences into some traditional Celtic stuff and then played some non-Irish stuff that was fun, including a medley of a whole bunch of Michael Jackson songs (instrumental only), and a set of extended solos by the low whistle player, the upright bass player, and the drummer while the fiddler tried to wring out his bow.  Each of the soloists demonstrated very impressive chops.  But we only got about half an hour of them before they were done for the night.

It was nice to see friends, and there was some good music, but if I'd realized how bad the weather would be I would have stayed home.

Tags: , ,

(3 comments | Leave a comment)

[User Picture]
Date:August 20th, 2007 11:35 am (UTC)
I was disappointed not to get to hear Scythian; they were fun to meet, and I heard many fun stories about them from my roommate at Dublin.

One group I'm sorry not to hear gossip about - you don't mention the Celtic Tenors! Ok, granted, they aren't going to have the same appeal for you as for me (good looking guys with great voices, singing....mmmm).

Glad you got to hear Liz & John.
[User Picture]
Date:August 22nd, 2007 02:32 am (UTC)
We planned to skip the Celtic Tenors based on the assumption that they would be singing operatically. As I quipped and others agreed, "I'm sure they have lovely voices, but they're using them wrong." I seem to have misplaced my program, but I think they were rained out anyway.
[User Picture]
Date:August 22nd, 2007 11:48 am (UTC)
They're a crossover band; they get flack from the opera lovers, too. ;-)

They have some elements of opera in their voices - James shows this the strongest - but they tone it down to more "popular" sounds, but maintain the strength, control and vibrancy that training has given them. They do a rather bizarre mixture of stuff; I think I prefer when they do everything but Irish pub songs, because those sound the most incongruous to my ear. They're very much a music theater sort of band, but that can be a lot of fun to watch.

Did you happen to see the write-up I did on them from Dublin for their fan club? Granted, very little of that actually covered the concert itself....
Powered by LiveJournal.com